Folks... What you are about to read is a real live word-for-word conversation I had with Amos via instant messenger. I copied this conversation and am pasting it here. The only changes have been spelling errors on both our parts and obvious grammatical errors.
Psych Majors... Enjoy.
HIM: I love you every day...including Monday. I hope you know that. And I hope you know it every day...
ME: Including Monday? Did we fight monday? I know you love me
HIM: This coming monday is the 14th
ME: Ah. Yes I know you love me. And I know Valentine's is against your religion.
HIM: I am going to love you equally that day as I do every day, which is the maximum. I want zero negative feelings. Only positive..like every other day in the year. Are we down with that? or...am I just going to get in trouble for something else or...I'm trying to get a barometer on your feelings. I am not just..telling you how it is. I'm trying to communicate and confer and make everything comfortable
ME: You know how I feel about valentines and I know how you feel about it. It's not new. While I doubt I will be overly happy on Valentines Day, I'm not going to yell at you if thats what you mean.
HIM: Its not about...yelling AT me..its about how you feel inside
ME: You know how I feel though so when you ask "are we down with that" what am I supposed to say?
" Yeah I'm totally cool w/ everything"? For the last 6 years I've tried to enjoy valentines day WITH you and it just hasn't worked so wether you want to admit it or not you're kinda forcing my hand. I'm not being ugly about it. I'm just saying what it is and Monday will happen and there will be romantic stories all over the place. I'll just turn off the internet and in 24 hours it will be Tuesday and then it will be over.
HIM: It will be a positive great day..just like Tuesday and Sunday and every other day. Thats how I see it.
ME: K. Here's the thing about girls.... They go through their whole adolescent and adult life looking for "the one" and until they find him then Valentines is sooooo depressing. They look forward to the day when they can openly share the day in the year set aside for romance with that special guy who will celebrate with them and you can each spend some time to make the other feel special. There is ZERO of that with us. This isn't new It's not new feelings . I didn't bring valentines up because I know how you feel about it. And if you're just going to bring it up to tell me , yet again, how you feel about it... what's the point in bringing it up? Just to remind me that Monday is gonna be weird?
HIM: My hope was to make it not weird by discussing it ahead of time. If I said nothing...it feels like there would be expectations. And...the point is...that I love you every day and try to make every day special. Every day is valentines day. Every day is maximum. You are special to me every day. Why only have special one day?
ME: Okay. Don't worry. I had and have no expectations.
HIM: Thats good right?
ME: It's a cop out. The thought is nice but it's a cop out. We don't need to have this conversation. It's not going to make you happy.
HIM: I'm happy. I refuse to be anything but happy. I want you to be happy too.
ME: Okay. I really wish you hadn't brought that up. Now it's all I'm thinking about and I'm hurt and mad.
HIM: I'm sorry. Not my intention.
ME: Why would you do that other than to just ensure that there were no expectations and to squash that thought right off the bat?
HIM: I wanted you to be happy and feel loved.
ME: By telling me you refuse to celebrate a holiday that I enjoy?!?! Yeah I'm feeling the love.
HIM: I wanted to say something ahead of time rather than say nothing...and then have this crushing thing happen on Monday.
ME: WHY would I expect ANYTHING on Monday other than the same exact big fat nothing that's happened every other year? All you did was rub me raw and hurt me . You say you care about my feelings on the subject but you care about them only as far as they don't interfere with your own.
HIM: I disagree with that.
ME: It's certainly what your actions are saying.
HIM: What actions have spoken to you to tell you that I only care about your feelings only as long as they don't interfere with my own?
ME: Valentines day for the past six years. I suppose it's the lack of actions that confirms it.
HIM: Every choice I make revolves around you. And I'm happy that it does. I love you. I wouldn't have it any other way.
ME: So you express it by making sure I have no special expectations on Monday? Let me make this clear.... I have ZERO expectations. I have never had any expections. You have made it perfectly clear to me that Valentines Day is a coorporate rip off and those who celebrate are poor blind sheep being led to the slaughter. And you specialness has given you that unique perspective that no one else has been blessed with. I get it. Please stop rubbing it in. It's hurtful .
HIM: To say special implies there's a day when its not special. Everyday is special.
ME: Ever day is special is bull crap. Its a cop out. Don't use it again unless you intend to make it so.
HIM: It is so
ME: Let's please shut the matter and never talk aboiut it again
HIM: You brought it up on your blog. January 20th. That's what makes me think something is up in terms of expectations.
ME: I made it very clear, I thought, that we didn't celebrate Valentines because you hate it. That entire post was dedicated to the fact that we WON'T be celebrating it.
HIM: But that's not the reason. It's not about me hating it or not.
ME: What's it about?
HIM: We don't celebrate it for the same reason we don't celebrate Hanukah. No reason to emphasize something that is at maximum emphasis every day of the year. That is the point.
ME: Really? Let's think about this. I have been suffering from lack of romantic attention for a long time. But this is a PERFECT excuse to make me feel special... a great day set aside to celebrate romance. But instead of honoring my feelings on it (thereby making me feel loved) you choose to boycott because it is already at it's "maximum emphasis." Your logic is skewed and flawed.
HIM: Disagree we have luniversaries
( side note, a lunarversary is our once monthy date night. ) and anniversaries that are continuous throughout the year. We have us all the time. The logic is solid. I'm not saying I have been the romantic expert at all times or anything , obviously I haven't... trying to work on that. But...even through the weak times...its been at maximum.
ME: Well since we're talking about MY feelings on the subject I think I can confidantly say that my love bank is NOT filled. But apparently that doesn't matter. I dont want to talk about this anymore. How many times do I have to say to let it drop? Youre just hurting me more and I'm begining to think that maybe you're just trying to pick a fight.
HIM: Trying to avoid any confrontation by dealing with it directly ahead of time.
ME: There wouldn't have been any if you had just let it lie. We don't celebrate V Day because you hate it. I get it. You can paint it however you want to. But that's the way it is.
HIM: Which is , of course, not why we don't celebrate it.
ME: Let's please drop it.
HIM: Ok..dropped
EDIT:
Let me also add that for the past two days (and other various times) he's checked his email in the mornings (a no-no since his prime porn time is in the morning while checking email). AND the other night he got onto the DEX website to request that they not send us telephone books anymore. He was trying to do so via live chat and ended up talking to this girl about random crap which ended up with her wanting his FACEBOOK ID SO THEY CAN BE FRIENDS (which he denied, thank GOD). I WASN'T home at the time so we, YET AGAIN, broke the "no internet alone time" rule. He cares NILCH about my feelings. The next time he tries to hand me a line of crap like "Every day is special" and "I want you to feel loved" I swear I'm going to throw something. I'm not an effing IDIOT.
Amos cares about what makes AMOS happy. Screw Esther. Maybe we'll get lucky and Esther won't find out.
I'm going to go cry now.